Marshall vs Penn State Prediction, Picks & Odds — Sep 5, 2026

Penn State is favored by more than three touchdowns while replacing nearly everything that produced for it: 48 players out, 38 in, a net loss of 33 recruiting stars, with five-star edge Chaz Coleman gone to Tennessee and Zuriah Fisher to USC. Nine percent of last season's passing production is back and none of the rushing. Marshall walks in with 96 percent of its passing production and all of its rushing production intact, the rare 24-point underdog that knows exactly who it is.

0%

-38

1%

-32

1%

-24

4%

-18

8%

-10

12%

-4

16%

+4

18%

+10

16%

+18

12%

+24

7%

+32

3%

+38

2%

+46

Marshall winsPenn State wins

Market: Penn State −24Projected: Penn State by 10 (73%)

The range of outcomes for this game. Each bar is how often the final margin lands in that range — the more it leans toward Penn State, the more likely Penn State wins.

GRIDPEX.COM

Marshall kept its offense; Penn State bought one

Carlos Del Rio-Wilson is a returning starter with three FBS seasons and +0.190 career EPA per play, and he is throwing to the same two receivers who made last season work. Adrian Norton produced +0.99 EPA per play on a 13 percent target share, De'Andre Tamarez +0.76 on 14 percent. Those are legitimately efficient secondary targets, and the #26 passing offense they built is still, roster-for-roster, the same passing offense.

Penn State's answer is Rocco Becht, four FBS seasons and +0.264 EPA per play, the more accomplished quarterback by a hair, and he did not arrive alone. Chase Sowell followed him from Iowa State, giving this offense its one pairing with shared reps already banked. Behind them, tight end Andrew Rappleyea at +0.53 EPA on a 10 percent target share is the only returning target in State College with a track record here.

Penn State's 48 departures are not an elite program churning backups: the position-weighted net is minus 25, and Coleman and Fisher are the two players who made last season's #32 pass defense rank there. What returns is Tony Rojas at two sacks, Daryus Dixson at one, and Audavion Collins with 45 tackles and none. Treat that #32 as unverified for this roster until someone on it wins a snap off the edge.

◄MarshallfavorsPenn State►

Last season's body of worklast year's power rating, regressed toward the averagePenn State +9

Returning productionhow much of last year's production is back this seasonMarshall +8

Roster talentoverall talent level of the roster — recruiting pedigree plus an independent preseason roster gradePenn State +4

Quarterbackthe projected starter's quality and how settled the job isPenn State +1

Each ingredient of our projection and the side it favors — bars toward Penn State are why it's the pick (home field is counted separately).

GRIDPEX.COM

The one matchup Marshall actually wins

Marshall's passing offense against Penn State's passing defense tilts to the visitors by 0.8 standard deviations, and it is the only crossing on the board that does. Full continuity attacking a rebuilt pass rush is the shape of an underdog cover: Del Rio-Wilson projects for 112 to 225 passing yards with a 75 percent chance of a touchdown, and he gets to throw at a group still deciding who its pressure player is.

Marshall returns 100 percent of a rushing offense that finished #104, and Joshon Barbie's -0.02 EPA per play on a 15 percent share is why it finished there. Penn State's #71 run defense takes that battle by 0.8 standard deviations, modest on its own and decisive against an offense with no second gear. Del Rio-Wilson has to carry the possession count himself, and Marshall's 20 projected points reflect exactly that.

Marshall takes the ball away; Penn State doesn't

Marshall intercepted 13 passes last season, 20th nationally, and the two players most responsible are back: Boogie Trotter with five picks, five breakups and 73 tackles, and safety Daytione Smith with three more. Penn State managed six interceptions all year, 102nd, and the edge rushers who forced those throws are gone. Trotter and Smith get Becht in September with a receiving corps he met in spring, and that is where Marshall's extra possessions come from.

The cost of that ball-hawking is a pass defense that ranked #108, near the bottom of the sport, and it just lost corner Tayvon Nelson and edge Paul Hutson III. Braydin Ward's four sacks are the returning pressure. Aumad Edwards from Kentucky, Keydel Painter and Iowa State's BJ Carter have to make that unit merely bad rather than a liability, or Becht throws past it on early downs all afternoon.

Marshall spreads it around; Penn State has two known targets

No Marshall receiver projects past 58 yards: Norton at 29 to 58 with a 43 percent touchdown chance, Tamarez 15 to 50, Toby Payne 19 to 45, Zion Turner 14 to 35 on the ground. That is a short-throw afternoon spread across four names rather than a plan built on isolating one mismatch, and it is the profile of an offense that reaches 20 points without ever threatening to run away from anybody.

Koby Howard at 21 to 34 receiving yards and Rappleyea at 15 to 31 with a 32 percent touchdown chance are the only Penn State pass-catchers with usable history, and Rappleyea's came on a 10 percent share. Chase Sowell arrives from Iowa State with no snaps in this offense. The other 91 percent of last season's passing volume belonged to players who left, so the targets have to land somewhere nobody can point to yet.

Marshall's honest path to +24.2

Marshall ranks 97th in talent but 61st in results, a roster that has beaten its recruiting for a while, and full continuity is the mechanism that keeps it happening. The projected 29-20 finish sits 15 points inside the number, with Penn State covering roughly one time in five. Marshall's requirements are the achievable ones: even turnovers, drives that end in kicks rather than three-and-outs, and Trotter taking one of Becht's early throws.

Penn State's pass rush is the unresolved question

Penn State needs Becht and Sowell to look like the Iowa State pairing they were, and it needs someone to replace Coleman's pressure before Del Rio-Wilson settles in; that edge is the one job on this roster with no returning answer. Marshall needs Barbie and the #104 run game functional enough to keep Del Rio-Wilson out of obvious throwing downs. A one-score finish projects at about a one-in-three chance, and the cover is far likelier than the outright.